A number of criminal cases have failed because of mistakes elsewhere in the justice system, rather than police errors.
Angelo Gafà, Commissioner of Police
There is evidence of errors outside the police force causing charges or appeals to fail. However, the available information does not establish how frequently this happens.How we reached this verdict ↓
Analysis and evaluation
Gafà argues that the police sometimes receive the blame for cases undermined by errors made by the Attorney General’s office or the courts.
The Attorney General’s office should be distinguished from both the police and the courts. It is responsible for conducting prosecutions and handling appeals, while the courts decide cases. Police officers also prosecute some cases, so the term “prosecution error” does not necessarily mean an error by the Attorney General. The office’s own explanation sets out these overlapping responsibilities.
Documented failures include the Attorney General citing the wrong legal provision, leading to acquittals that were upheld on appeal. In other proceedings, its office filed an appeal after the deadline, preventing the appeal from being considered, or withdrew charges based on legislation introduced after the alleged offences. These were errors in the legal handling of proceedings, rather than failures to investigate the alleged crimes.
There are also judicial errors confirmed on appeal. In a decision reported in 2026, the appeal court found that the first court had wrongly refused the prosecution additional time to bring an essential witness, despite its attempts to summon him. It ordered a new hearing. The initial acquittal therefore did not result from the prosecution neglecting to secure that witness.
This supports Gafà’s central point: a failed case is not automatically a police failure. But the consequences differ: some errors defeat particular charges, others prevent an appeal, and others can be corrected through a new hearing. The evidence supports the existence of the problem, without establishing that it accounts for a substantial proportion of unsuccessful cases.
Editorial note
How we assessed this claim
The assessment concerns the identified procedural errors and their consequences.
Limitations
- An acquittal alone does not establish that any institution made a mistake.
Sources
- Attorney General, Prosecution Unit: division of responsibilities
- MaltaToday, Acquittal upheld following an error in the applicable legal provisions (23 March 2023)
- MaltaToday, Appeal rejected for missing the filing deadline (26 September 2025)
- The Malta Independent, Charges withdrawn after a legislative error (18 January 2023)
- Awla, New hearing ordered after an essential witness was not heard (5 August 2026)